Boarding a plane as an economics problem

Warning: this content is older than 365 days. It may be out of date and no longer relevant.

The airline industry’s boarding and deplaning process is, generally speaking, about as organized as an overweight cattle stampede. If you’ve been on a plane recently, as I’ve been, you know the pain and frustration of watching fellow passengers who seem to pack a couple of freight containers in their carry on, then are surprised when they don’t fit in the overhead compartments, then get belligerent with you, with each other, and with the crew because they packed too damn much.

This is an economics problem. The moment airlines started charging for checked baggage, the boarding and deplaning problem got worse because passengers started carrying EVERYTHING with them. I saw one guy on the flight down to Tampa with his suit pockets bulging with AC adapters and a laptop bag that looked like it would burst. His carry on was so full that the zipper teeth were actually being strained, and it took him a good 15 minutes to sit down finally – thankfully not in my row. His fellow passengers were undoubtedly moments away from demonstrating creative uses of portable electronics and body cavities.

So how do you fix this?

If the airlines wanted to speed up boarding and departure times and still make margins, they’d reverse the charges – charge for carry-ons and make checked luggage free. Imagine if you incurred a 25 or50 charge for each item larger than one cubic foot, with a simple plexiglas box at check-in. Fits in the box? Free. Doesn’t fit? You get charged.

There would be a side benefit to this as well. Lines at security would move MUCH faster. Imagine if the TSA only had to screen one bag per person. At most, you’d have maybe two items per person if a piece of portable electronic gear was involved.

Shorter, faster moving lines at security. Shorter, faster moving lines in the aisle of your aircraft as you get on and off your plane. Passengers with connections would be more likely to make the connections. Fewer concussions when the Druish Princess’ industry hair dryer can’t bean someone on the skull opening an overhead compartment.

All through the miracle of economics.

Did you enjoy this blog post? If so, please subscribe right now!

Boarding a plane as an economics problem 1 Boarding a plane as an economics problem 2 Boarding a plane as an economics problem 3

Get this and other great articles from the source at www.ChristopherSPenn.com

Comments

11 responses to “Boarding a plane as an economics problem”

  1. Benny Lewis Avatar

    You’re going to hate me 😛 Right now on my blog I’m promoting the very problem you talk about; squeezing everything you can into your carry on.

  2. Daniel Johnson, Jr. Avatar

    I haven't flown since 1990. I know that the next time I do, I'm in for quite a rude awakening.

  3. Daniel Johnson, Jr. Avatar

    I haven't flown since 1990. I know that the next time I do, I'm in for quite a rude awakening.

  4. Mark Blevis Avatar

    Okay. This is nothing short of brilliant. With all of the travel I have done of late in which I have observed everything about carry-on luggage that you've described, your solution would make the passenger experience more comfortable and less frustrating.

    Take it to the top, Chris! Start with United Airlines. With the way they're mishandling themselves, they need all the help they can get.

  5. Joe Avatar
    Joe

    Great post. Many, many things can be broken down this way. For some reason, when you are elevated to the role of VP or CEO, all sorts of common sense goes out the window. Take another form of mass transit – BART/Caltrain (for those in the SF bay area). The solution to increased operating costs? Increased ticket prices. This in turn causes tickets sales to drop as the cost-benefit ratio declines. The remaining passengers pay even more over time. How in the world does this translate into sustainable mass transit?

    My other pet peeve that might be closer to you – 529 accounts. Why are 529 accounts not tax deductible in my state (CA)? If I am saving for my my childs' education, I am not only investing in their future, but the future of the state/country (one could argue)….incentivize me. Gym memberships and other health related activities too. You want me to be healthy, give me a discount/tax break on healthy activities. Imagine the savings we as tax payers would have on health care costs!

    At the end of the day, a large part of our cultures problems are caused by bad economic policies. We all too frequently encourage the wrong type of behavior. If the systems that affect us all are setup properly, a lot of our problems would be minimized, if not eliminated outright.

  6. Mark Blevis Avatar

    Okay. This is nothing short of brilliant. With all of the travel I have done of late in which I have observed everything about carry-on luggage that you've described, your solution would make the passenger experience more comfortable and less frustrating.

    Take it to the top, Chris! Start with United Airlines. With the way they're mishandling themselves, they need all the help they can get.

  7. Joe Avatar
    Joe

    Great post. Many, many things can be broken down this way. For some reason, when you are elevated to the role of VP or CEO, all sorts of common sense goes out the window. Take another form of mass transit – BART/Caltrain (for those in the SF bay area). The solution to increased operating costs? Increased ticket prices. This in turn causes tickets sales to drop as the cost-benefit ratio declines. The remaining passengers pay even more over time. How in the world does this translate into sustainable mass transit?

    My other pet peeve that might be closer to you – 529 accounts. Why are 529 accounts not tax deductible in my state (CA)? If I am saving for my my childs’ education, I am not only investing in their future, but the future of the state/country (one could argue)….incentivize me. Gym memberships and other health related activities too. You want me to be healthy, give me a discount/tax break on healthy activities. Imagine the savings we as tax payers would have on health care costs!

    At the end of the day, a large part of our cultures problems are caused by bad economic policies. We all too frequently encourage the wrong type of behavior. If the systems that affect us all are setup properly, a lot of our problems would be minimized, if not eliminated outright.

  8.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    The moment airlines started charging for checked baggage, the boarding and deplaning problem got worse because passengers started carrying EVERYTHING with them.

  9. aaronasjones Avatar
    aaronasjones

    Thank you for sharing this information.
    Reverse Access Livedoor

  10.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Thank you for sharing this information.
    Reverse Access Livedoor

  11. Codes Avatar

    Hmm..tahts really great post..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Shares
Share This